所有案件
失落的城市 的案件
#4056: "Opponent was allowed to draw when zero cards remained"
這是關於哪方面的案件？
發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇
規則：遊戲規則有所錯漏
細節描述
• 遊戲規則的哪部分在 BGA 版本有所錯漏？
Opponent was allowed to draw when zero cards remained• 這項違反規則之處可否在遊戲重播中看到？若可以是在哪步？（重播時左上角資訊）
I don't know, this was at the end of the game.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼？
Google Chrome v47
案件沿革
2015年12月14日 18:59 • lasultanerousse • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Opponent was allowed to draw when zero cards remained so he won unfairly the game!?
2016年 1月10日 16:42 • jokari • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Bonjour, mon adversaire a gagné en jouant un coup de plus qui a conduit la pioche a - 1, ceci m'est déjà arrivé plusieurs fois. c'est assez destabilisant. Et fausse par consequent les scores.
2016年 2月 2日 4:30 • nandblock • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same problem here. Here's the final tableau. imgur.com/RDWxXMV
I noticed at the START of the game something odd--it looked like 2 cards went to my opponent drew their first card from the deck. Possibly related.
I noticed at the START of the game something odd--it looked like 2 cards went to my opponent drew their first card from the deck. Possibly related.
2016年 2月14日 9:00 • Mwakari • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same issues , see 2 times in one week, my opponent was allow to play and draw until -1 table 19255777 coup 99
2016年 3月22日 2:54 • HuGeGamer • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I just played Wonder woman in lost cities. There was one card left in the draw pile and it was my turn. I played my last card which gave me a higher total than Wonder Woman. I was pleased thinking I had won and drew the last card. The next thing I knew I see her placing a 10 on a pile and drawing a card from the draw pile ( which now showed -1 instead of 0. The last card she played (after the game was over) counted and it gave her the win. It looked more like a "CHEAT/HACK" than it did a bug.
2016年 5月 2日 18:42 • florrat • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I had the same problem on table #21050630. Also, as nandblock, at the start of the game, on the first turn of my opponent, it displayed the animation that my opponent drew a card twice on that turn. This probably happened because of some connection issues or lag.
So almost surely the number of cards in the deck was off by 1 for the entire game. Hence this is a duplicate of bug 3713.
This is a display bug, refreshing the page fixed it for me. A screenshot of the end of the game (before refreshing):
i.imgur.com/ynYcttg.jpg
So almost surely the number of cards in the deck was off by 1 for the entire game. Hence this is a duplicate of bug 3713.
This is a display bug, refreshing the page fixed it for me. A screenshot of the end of the game (before refreshing):
i.imgur.com/ynYcttg.jpg
2020年 4月30日 0:16 • bmcfluff • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
There are lots of votes here, but the last comment was in 2016 and I am not able to reproduce the bug so it's possible it was fixed. I am therefore marking this as "infoneeded" and will take no further action unless someone can provide current evidence that this bug still exists. And it sounds like it's an insidious display bug that doesn't show up in replay, so please describe anything unusual that happens in your comment here - in particular, did you notice a player seeming to get two draw animations in the same turn, and if so what turn was that.
2020年 8月29日 19:43 • Fluffy Baby Bunny • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
Just played this morning at table number 109471973.
Took a screen shot! Draw pile is at negative 1.
I wasn’t going to win, but I was going to only be down about 4 points. I was drawing off the board, then tried to take the last card to end it, and my opponent not only got another card, he got another play and ended up with another 18 points or so.
imgur.com/gallery/NAwZOIe
Took a screen shot! Draw pile is at negative 1.
I wasn’t going to win, but I was going to only be down about 4 points. I was drawing off the board, then tried to take the last card to end it, and my opponent not only got another card, he got another play and ended up with another 18 points or so.
imgur.com/gallery/NAwZOIe
2020年 8月29日 21:09 • bmcfluff • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Thanks for the report and the screenshot! Looks like you were also afflicted by another display bug (boardgamearena.com/bug?id=3741) - you can see in your screenshot that the yellow 10 and white 7 were duplicated in your tableau, and your displayed score was too high by the corresponding amount.
2020年 8月29日 21:16 • bmcfluff • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
To help me figure out what's going on, if anyone sees anything unusual in their game (e.g. a player appears to draw 2 cards on their turn), *before navigating away from the game* please copy over the contents of the developer console if possible (e.g. on Chrome on Windows, Ctrl+Shift+J).
2020年 8月31日 18:01 • zaitsevntu • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
#109809998
When the remaining card is 0 my opponent is still able to add card to tile, and finally I lost:(
When the remaining card is 0 my opponent is still able to add card to tile, and finally I lost:(
2020年10月17日 7:31 • Fluffy Baby Bunny • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Oh man. This bug is NOT solved. Just happened again at table number 117826984.
The draw pile is down to negative one at the end. It almost made me lose the game.
It doesn’t always happen, but I’ve seen it before (reported above).
It could be related to my poor interface on my iPhone. I sometimes have to refresh during a game, which might make it lose track of the draws somehow? But it’s not consistent. At the end of the game, when I take the last card from the draw pile, it lets my opponent take one more, and play it, so the draw pile is negative 1.
The draw pile is down to negative one at the end. It almost made me lose the game.
It doesn’t always happen, but I’ve seen it before (reported above).
It could be related to my poor interface on my iPhone. I sometimes have to refresh during a game, which might make it lose track of the draws somehow? But it’s not consistent. At the end of the game, when I take the last card from the draw pile, it lets my opponent take one more, and play it, so the draw pile is negative 1.
2020年10月19日 22:33 • Dzibeta • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Правила игры отличаются от представленного на арене.
Игроки сначала считают свои очки экспедиции, затем вычитаю 20 очков этой суммы и только затем итоговое число умножают на карточки пари.
Игроки сначала считают свои очки экспедиции, затем вычитаю 20 очков этой суммы и только затем итоговое число умножают на карточки пари.
2020年10月19日 23:50 • bmcfluff • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Hi Dzibeta,
It sounds like you posted your report in the wrong thread - this is the place for "OPPONENT WAS ALLOWED TO DRAW WHEN ZERO CARDS REMAINED", not scoring issues. You can post your issue here instead: boardgamearena.com/bug?id=3694 but please first carefully read the existing comments and the rulebook, because it also sounds like you (like many people in that thread) might just be misunderstanding the rules.
It sounds like you posted your report in the wrong thread - this is the place for "OPPONENT WAS ALLOWED TO DRAW WHEN ZERO CARDS REMAINED", not scoring issues. You can post your issue here instead: boardgamearena.com/bug?id=3694 but please first carefully read the existing comments and the rulebook, because it also sounds like you (like many people in that thread) might just be misunderstanding the rules.
2021年 4月25日 9:12 • Cedroc92 • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
2021年 4月25日 21:04 • bmcfluff • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Hi Cedroc92,
Thanks for additional evidence that this is still a problem. Unfortunately as you can see from the report status, I wrote what was hopefully a fix half a year ago, but we're still waiting on a site admin to check and deploy the fix.
Thanks for additional evidence that this is still a problem. Unfortunately as you can see from the report status, I wrote what was hopefully a fix half a year ago, but we're still waiting on a site admin to check and deploy the fix.
2022年 9月 1日 12:11 • KassHax1s • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Draw pile stayed on 'x1' for 2 extra turns that should not have happened. Changed the result of the game on table 296408190
2022年11月19日 23:53 • legendaryporch • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
2023年10月 7日 18:25 • Livini • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
I wonder if this is an information display bug. I once played a game where my opponent claimed that I took cards to a -1 draw pile, but unless I overlooked it, that's not what it said on my screen. This wasn't recently, so I can't tag the game.
2024年 1月 7日 18:35 • le viking occitan • 本案件已由工作室的獎勵獵人宣告解決，需要進一步檢測及實裝:
Same thing here, extra turn for opponent with -1 card remaining
為本案件添加內容
任何可能重現這項錯誤或了解你的建議之相關資訊，都請在此填寫:
- 其他同樣狀況的桌號／步數
- 按 F5 是否解決了這個問題？
- 問題是否發生了好幾次？每次都發生？時好時壞？
- 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
