boardgamearena.com/7/ultimaterailroads?table=327174738

I had the same issue with this game. onemorename had three engineers but got 20 points. opakarl had two engineers and got 40 points.

#384117173

I had 3 Engineers on the table and the End Game Card giving me an extra engineer. My opponent had 3 engineers on the table (plus the "Track-Engineer" which shouldnt count in the scoring) but he gained 40 points and I got 20 although it should be the other way round.

Looks like not a bug for me. You guys should read the game log and the rules. In table #299582634 plombiers hired Engineer #2 and #15 and Youshilechat hired Engineers #3, #4, #9 and #12. plombiers addionally gained Engineer #1 and took the virtual engineer bonus card resulting in both players having 4 engineers. In this case the tie breaker is the highest engineer number and plombiers therefore receives the 40 point by having engineer #15.

Same thing with table #327174738: opakarl (#2, #12, virtual engineer) and onemorename (#9, #5, #1). Both players have 3 engineers and opakarl gets the 40 VP because he has the highest rated engineer (#12).

Table #384117173 is even easier to explain: Of course engineer #1 also counts towards the engineer end game scoring. Therefore Matz_314 has 4 engineers and receives the 40 VP.

Me and my friend had the same amount of engineers but his value was bigger than mine. He got 20 points e and i got 40.

• Which part of the rules was not followed by the BGA adaptation?
The player with the most engineers scores 40 points
The player with the 2nd most engineers scores 20 points


• Is the rules violation visible on game replay? If yes, at which move number?
ncaproject (me) had 2 engineers with a sum of 19 and I scored 0 points at the end of the game (being third, while I should have been second).
Cogen (opponent) had 2 engineers with a sum of 15 and scored 20 points at the end of the game (being second, while he should be third).


• Which browser are you using?
Firefox

Table #703023414

imgur.com/a/U0ubYYl