所有案件
花火 的案件
#27692: "Game didn't end automatically when it should"
#27692: "Game didn't end automatically when it should"
這是關於哪方面的案件?
發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇
規則:遊戲規則有所錯漏
發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇
規則:遊戲規則有所錯漏
請檢查是否已有同課題案件
若肯定,請「投票」給這樁案件。最高票的案件將「優先」處理!
# | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
---|
細節描述
• 如果可以的話,請轉貼螢幕顯示的錯誤訊息。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 請說明你當時想做什麼,你做了什麼,然後發生了什麼事
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 請轉貼未翻譯的英文字句。 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 這些文字存在於 翻譯系統 中嗎?若為真,其是否已被翻譯超過 24 小時?
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 請簡明精確地解釋你的建議,以便讓人一目了然。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 當你不能動作時,螢幕上顯示什麼?(螢幕全黑?部份遊戲介面?錯誤訊息?)
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 遊戲規則的哪部分在 BGA 版本有所錯漏?
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 這項違反規則之處可否在遊戲重播中看到?若可以是在哪步?(重播時左上角資訊)
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 你當時想採取哪個遊戲行動?
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 你想觸發這個遊戲行動時做了什麼?
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 當你試著這麼做時發生了什麼(錯誤訊息、遊戲狀態條訊息...)?
• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 問題發生在遊戲的哪一步?(當前遊戲指示是什麼)
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 當你試著進行遊戲動作時發生了什麼(錯誤訊息、遊戲狀態條訊息...)?
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 請描述顯示問題。 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 請轉貼未翻譯的英文字句。 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 這些文字存在於 翻譯系統 中嗎?若為真,其是否已被翻譯超過 24 小時?
Move 77 is the last playable played, all other on the discard pile. End if the game is move 84/85 - so many actions required from players that already ended the game...• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
• 請簡明精確地解釋你的建議,以便讓人一目了然。
The game should end automatically if (before the deck is over) there is no more cards that can be played - in the players hand nor in the deck.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v86
案件沿革
2020年11月 6日 22:18 • Ankeszu • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Bug 27576 was the same, but it was marked "not a bug" for unknown reason (I assume admin misunderstood the description). Yes, old Hanabi tables were ending before the deck if there was no option for a valid play.
2020年11月 7日 2:30 • eirbmia • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Yes the same thing happened to me! I have no idea why the developers marked it as "not a bug"--it is. The previous version of Hanabi would end when no playable cards were available.
2020年11月 7日 8:33 • Lel0uch • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I have noticed this happens only when black variant cards are remaining to be played
Example: i had a game where 2 black was in discard pile, so 1 black couldn't be played. so we needed to finish the deck forcibly. Link to table: boardgamearena.com/table?table=121936178
Example: i had a game where 2 black was in discard pile, so 1 black couldn't be played. so we needed to finish the deck forcibly. Link to table: boardgamearena.com/table?table=121936178
2020年11月 8日 20:56 • Salanael • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Seems it was not fixed yet. Table #122594229
Black powder again (and 5 Flamboyant), maybe it's the cause.
Black powder again (and 5 Flamboyant), maybe it's the cause.
2020年11月11日 19:58 • 3mal7 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
another bug reporting this problem: boardgamearena.com/bug?id=27972
2020年11月12日 14:04 • aquarelle • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I think in these situations game should end automatically :
1) If flamboyants are off (and double discard on cards needed eg same situations as previous interface)
2) The flamboyants to play immediately a card from the deck or add to draw pile a card from the discard pile have been played + double discard or max score reached
1) If flamboyants are off (and double discard on cards needed eg same situations as previous interface)
2) The flamboyants to play immediately a card from the deck or add to draw pile a card from the discard pile have been played + double discard or max score reached
2020年11月13日 16:12 • Isayla • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same at table #123707209
Flamboyant and Black Powder active : we lost two 5 and the 1 black.
The partie not ends alone, although we have no more cards to play (last card played was a 5 Flamboyant which allow to clue a color - the game didn't end after the clue).
Flamboyant and Black Powder active : we lost two 5 and the 1 black.
The partie not ends alone, although we have no more cards to play (last card played was a 5 Flamboyant which allow to clue a color - the game didn't end after the clue).
2020年11月16日 22:54 • NaceWindu • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I just experienced this with only black powder turned on. Table # 124656997
2020年11月17日 3:56 • VitaminZ • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I also have this with black powder only. Black one is unplayable but game doesn't realize this? table=124697457
2020年11月19日 11:46 • spressi • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same problem at table #123920328
It most likely has to do with the check for playable cards left being implemented incorrectly for black powder cards. (Relatedly, black cards should be arranged in reverse order in the discard pile from 5 to 1)
Besides considering the reverse order for black powder cards, there is no additional rule necessary to check for the premature end of the game (flamboyants can be completely ignored, see below).
@aquarelle: These rules are not necessary because there has to be a playable card left in order to trigger a flamboyant. Therefore, no playable card being left in the deck or on any player's hand implies that there is no chance of recovery left.
It most likely has to do with the check for playable cards left being implemented incorrectly for black powder cards. (Relatedly, black cards should be arranged in reverse order in the discard pile from 5 to 1)
Besides considering the reverse order for black powder cards, there is no additional rule necessary to check for the premature end of the game (flamboyants can be completely ignored, see below).
@aquarelle: These rules are not necessary because there has to be a playable card left in order to trigger a flamboyant. Therefore, no playable card being left in the deck or on any player's hand implies that there is no chance of recovery left.
2020年11月26日 21:06 • thom_h • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
First off, I want to tip my hat to the development team for this fun new version of Hanabi and all the UI upgrades in the past weeks.
I was playing the Black Powder variant, and the game end did not trigger when all playable Black Powder cards had been played.
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/rFIJIPt
Table 127062781 / Move 85
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201126-0918/?table=127062781&player=84145696&comments=84859130;&goto=85
I also reviewed the previous few games in the Report History above and found that the game end did not trigger for the same set of game conditions: all playable black powder cards had been played.
Table: 123920328 / Move: 92
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=123920328&player=84730882&comments=84859130;&goto=92
Table: 124656997 / Move 72
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=124656997&player=84286214&comments=84859130;&goto=72
Table 124463931 / Move 87
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=124463931&player=87228878&comments=84859130;&goto=87
I was playing the Black Powder variant, and the game end did not trigger when all playable Black Powder cards had been played.
Screenshot: imgur.com/a/rFIJIPt
Table 127062781 / Move 85
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201126-0918/?table=127062781&player=84145696&comments=84859130;&goto=85
I also reviewed the previous few games in the Report History above and found that the game end did not trigger for the same set of game conditions: all playable black powder cards had been played.
Table: 123920328 / Move: 92
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=123920328&player=84730882&comments=84859130;&goto=92
Table: 124656997 / Move 72
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=124656997&player=84286214&comments=84859130;&goto=72
Table 124463931 / Move 87
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201112-0929/?table=124463931&player=87228878&comments=84859130;&goto=87
2020年11月26日 21:08 • thom_h • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I forgot to mention that I added comments to the replays 4 games listed at the time the game end should be triggered.
2020年11月28日 7:55 • thom_h • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Here is another example:
imgur.com/a/APd1tfk
Table: 127418165 / Move 95
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201127-1050/?table=127418165&player=84859130&comments=84859130;&goto=95
imgur.com/a/APd1tfk
Table: 127418165 / Move 95
boardgamearena.com/archive/replay/201127-1050/?table=127418165&player=84859130&comments=84859130;&goto=95
2020年11月30日 20:47 • Bezu74 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same bug on game 128069476, move 93.
To end the game we had to discard until there was no more cards in the deck and no more move alowed...
To end the game we had to discard until there was no more cards in the deck and no more move alowed...
2020年12月31日 1:32 • gr33kdude • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
This bug occurred on table #135372367 as well.
Playing with Avalanche of Colors and Black Powder, but Flamboyants OFF.
We had no point-gaining moves left to play toward the end of the game (I think around move 93), but the game did not immediately end so we still had to continue playing. This wasn't a big deal since we didn't have many cards left, but it seemed like an improvement/bug to report, and sure enough we found this thread existed too.
Playing with Avalanche of Colors and Black Powder, but Flamboyants OFF.
We had no point-gaining moves left to play toward the end of the game (I think around move 93), but the game did not immediately end so we still had to continue playing. This wasn't a big deal since we didn't have many cards left, but it seemed like an improvement/bug to report, and sure enough we found this thread existed too.
2020年12月31日 5:36 • ComplixVandh • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
same problem on table 135410797. Black 1 was discarded and the game kept going when we were at 29 (flamboyant 5 off).
2021年 3月 2日 18:25 • Isayla • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Another exemple : the game is not ending when black card are not finish. Even if those black card were discarded.
2 games, whith discard of the 1 black : did not end when all the 5 are played and the black from 5 to 2. We should end remaining cards and the last turn :
boardgamearena.com/table?table=152361784
boardgamearena.com/table?table=152363690
Only whith black cards, when it's a 5 that has been discard and if black cards are all played, the game is ending.
2 games, whith discard of the 1 black : did not end when all the 5 are played and the black from 5 to 2. We should end remaining cards and the last turn :
boardgamearena.com/table?table=152361784
boardgamearena.com/table?table=152363690
Only whith black cards, when it's a 5 that has been discard and if black cards are all played, the game is ending.
2021年 3月 4日 21:11 • Baleae • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
This error happen also in this table
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=152925080
Was in normal multicolor
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=152925080
Was in normal multicolor
2021年 3月 6日 20:26 • segfaltnh • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Just saw this in table#153454624. As others report, seems to be that black 1 was lost, and we had completed all other stacks but remaining turns still had to be played out.
2021年 3月10日 22:25 • crashBB • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Hanabi #154539097
Same problem : all colored 5s had been played and two black cards could be played but the game ended prematurely
Same problem : all colored 5s had been played and two black cards could be played but the game ended prematurely
2021年 3月13日 13:51 • IvettCs • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
It happened to me. We finished the game, so I thought. Put the phone down and came back to find out I'd been dispelled and 20 points deducted. Without the bug, the game would have automatically ended. With the current ELO points being ridiculously hard to keep up, that's frustrating.
2021年 4月26日 23:56 • Silene • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Wow, just found out it also works the other way around: The game does end even though there are still cards in the deck and we have playable black cards.
Probably not a coincidence, that our Black stack was at 5. But 4 and 3 were still in our hands and ready to play.
Looks like the code is at some point checking whether the stacks are at 5 without regard to the fact that black is played backwards.
boardgamearena.com/5/hanabi?table=167586125
Probably not a coincidence, that our Black stack was at 5. But 4 and 3 were still in our hands and ready to play.
Looks like the code is at some point checking whether the stacks are at 5 without regard to the fact that black is played backwards.
boardgamearena.com/5/hanabi?table=167586125
2021年 6月19日 1:53 • BlindNexi • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
1k is in the discard and all other playable cards have been played.
boardgamearena.com/6/hanabi?table=181213165
boardgamearena.com/6/hanabi?table=181213165
2021年 6月29日 0:10 • Je me souviens • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
The game was finished, we had all the Fives identified but I was not able to continue
2021年 9月23日 2:59 • Crowdel • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
same happened on table #203898832 I think it relates to having flamboyants and BP on. The last card to be played would have been a BP1 which was impossible as all other tracks were full (no flamboyant possible) and likely due to how it tracks 1's (there are 3 in standard play with only 1 for BP track)
2021年12月30日 6:18 • arisanana • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Bump with this table as well, since there aren't enough mentions that this happens when not only black 1 is unretrievable from the discard pile, but also both black 2's are unretrievable, and possibly any black number that is completely unretrievable.
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=227823374
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=227823374
2022年 1月 4日 4:40 • arisanana • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Game finished at like 7 cards left, black1 left in discard pile so game wouldn't end
boardgamearena.com/1/hanabi?table=229289516
boardgamearena.com/1/hanabi?table=229289516
2022年 2月17日 19:17 • spressi • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I can confirm that this bug only occurs when flamboyants are on. In this game without flamboyants, the game ended correctly: boardgamearena.com/9/hanabi?table=241892286
The weird thing about this is that the algorithm for deciding whether or not to end the game prematurely should be independent from whether or not flamboyants are on. As soon as no more cards can be played, there is also no more chance to trigger a flamboyant. Thus, if you only take that part of the code that is executed without flamboyants and apply it to every game, the bug should be fixed.
The weird thing about this is that the algorithm for deciding whether or not to end the game prematurely should be independent from whether or not flamboyants are on. As soon as no more cards can be played, there is also no more chance to trigger a flamboyant. Thus, if you only take that part of the code that is executed without flamboyants and apply it to every game, the bug should be fixed.
2022年 2月18日 22:54 • arisanana • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
I've always wondered about that person above somewhere who said the game ended when the board was all 5s because i've gotten all 5s... ? i think? before? and i finally ran into a similar situation myself:
settings: avalanche/black/flamboyants on
final situation: have k4 and k3 to play before game should end, but both k2s were discarded so the moment the last playable 5 went on the game ended
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=243488440
settings: avalanche/black/flamboyants on
final situation: have k4 and k3 to play before game should end, but both k2s were discarded so the moment the last playable 5 went on the game ended
boardgamearena.com/4/hanabi?table=243488440
2022年 2月19日 14:04 • spressi • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
And another example where it didn't end despite flamboyants off: boardgamearena.com/3/hanabi?table=242862205
2022年 2月28日 14:27 • Wouter77 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
table 246284292, move 76: only black 1 left to play, but was in discard
2022年 3月30日 9:36 • spressi • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
table 253117729, move 82
boardgamearena.com/9/hanabi?table=253117729&replayFrom=82
boardgamearena.com/9/hanabi?table=253117729&replayFrom=82
2022年 5月21日 10:25 • lili13 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
The game doesn’t end correctly when all black cards haven’t been played. This is systematic.
2022年 7月17日 3:09 • Silene • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Still bugged : boardgamearena.com/table?table=283921228
Game ends after k5 played while we still had k4 in hand.
Game ends after k5 played while we still had k4 in hand.
2022年 9月13日 20:44 • fufumdr • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Needless to give redudant examples saying it's not fixed. This is quite obvious.
But games like the ones Silene pointed out are a serious issue.
Game ends despite PLAYABLE cards still beeing in hands (and deck isn't empty).
THIS is much more important than having to skip a few turns discarding or giving useless clues !
But games like the ones Silene pointed out are a serious issue.
Game ends despite PLAYABLE cards still beeing in hands (and deck isn't empty).
THIS is much more important than having to skip a few turns discarding or giving useless clues !
2023年 4月 8日 3:14 • justameer • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Playing Hanabi, 4 player game, we just finished all six stacks (multicolor) which should have finished the game but the play discard flamboyant wouldn't let play or click anything. Kept giving different instructions and "cannot make move" error.
A shame cause it was so satisfying, then so devasting to feel as a newer player lol.
A shame cause it was so satisfying, then so devasting to feel as a newer player lol.
2023年 4月15日 20:42 • hagawaga • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Still happening, only 1k left but it is in the discard pile table=367389508
2023年 4月25日 8:03 • Malo77 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Same problem, 1k in discard pile and when playing the last 5 with flamb, the game did not ended properly. All cards were played except the 1k in the discard, and the game did not ended. We had to discard our cards to end the draw pile. boardgamearena.com/5/hanabi?table=370618816
see moves 93-94
see moves 93-94
2023年 4月27日 16:03 • Wouter77 • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
table 371394042. 28 cards played and W5 and K1 were out. So no cards left that could be played
2023年 7月 7日 17:03 • MikkoH • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
In table 394472614, game didn't end when all playable cards had been played (no flamboyants). Black 5 had been played and both black 4 were already discarded. Game ended automatically when the last black 2 was discarded.
Hypothesis for root cause: This game and discussion above makes it look like the root cause could be that the code that checks for end game isn't aware of black cards going in different order. Behaviour was consistent with "one black card has been played, therefore next playable card is black two, and that's still in somebody's hand", when correct would have been "one black card has been played, therefore the next playable card is black 4, and that's no longer available"
Hypothesis for root cause: This game and discussion above makes it look like the root cause could be that the code that checks for end game isn't aware of black cards going in different order. Behaviour was consistent with "one black card has been played, therefore next playable card is black two, and that's still in somebody's hand", when correct would have been "one black card has been played, therefore the next playable card is black 4, and that's no longer available"
2023年 7月 7日 17:05 • SKZdman • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
Table #394472614
We lost both k4 early in game, then the game didn't end when we had no playable cards. Finally ended when player discarded the final k2.
I think that the game rules are looking for k1 > k5, (like with all other colours) rather than k5 > k1.
As a fix, maybe code k1-5 to work the same way as other colours, but point to the sprites in reverse?
We lost both k4 early in game, then the game didn't end when we had no playable cards. Finally ended when player discarded the final k2.
I think that the game rules are looking for k1 > k5, (like with all other colours) rather than k5 > k1.
As a fix, maybe code k1-5 to work the same way as other colours, but point to the sprites in reverse?
2023年10月 5日 13:26 • tetack • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
table 424913674
after move 90 no more card available - game don't stop until deck is empty .
maybe link with 1 black
after move 90 no more card available - game don't stop until deck is empty .
maybe link with 1 black
2023年10月19日 16:02 • dencho • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
4 black was still in deck and game ended saying no more cards playable. Thanks in advance to remove ELO loss resulting from this game.
2024年 5月 3日 14:28 • Mahelma • 開發者尚未重現這項錯誤:
507937723
here again, 2*4bk were in trash and the game didn't end
here again, 2*4bk were in trash and the game didn't end
為本案件添加內容
任何可能重現這項錯誤或了解你的建議之相關資訊,都請在此填寫:
- 其他同樣狀況的桌號/步數
- 按 F5 是否解決了這個問題?
- 問題是否發生了好幾次?每次都發生?時好時壞?
- 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
更改案件狀態為:
bug?id=27692