所有案件
大西部開拓者 的案件
#56667: "Displaying player board on the left or right sometimes requires F5 to display correctly "
這是關於哪方面的案件？
發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇
顯示異常：部分遊戲資訊顯示錯誤（未造成嚴重後果）
細節描述
• 請描述顯示問題。 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
imgur.com/a/4pOuob8
Using Chrome.
Sometimes it works fine and sometimes it gives things like shown in the screenshot.
Problem typically occurs with zooming > 100% or when the browser window is small.
F5 solves this problem.
Also, sometimes when fiddling around with the zoom after having set the boards to appear left or right, the user preferences will revert to bottom without any input on my part.
This was tested at the very start of the game.
2nd edition board.• 你的瀏覽器是什麼？
Google Chrome v96
案件沿革
2022年 1月 7日 14:43 • docthib • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
Hello again,
We had this issue before but it has been fixed.
I was unable to reproduce this display even when playing with Chrome zoom.
Don't you have a way to reproduce issue every time? Did you try CTRL+F5?
And yes it's normal (not a bug) it reverts to bottom if you don't have enough space to display boards on right or left :)
We had this issue before but it has been fixed.
I was unable to reproduce this display even when playing with Chrome zoom.
Don't you have a way to reproduce issue every time? Did you try CTRL+F5?
And yes it's normal (not a bug) it reverts to bottom if you don't have enough space to display boards on right or left :)
2022年 1月 7日 15:51 • Phoxtrot • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
Yes, F5 and CTRL_F5 solves this so it's not very important.
I have a 1920-1080 screen.
Chrome window is maxed, windows toolbar is displayed below chrome, bookmarks and address bar are taking some space at the top of Chrome.
Font size is 100% (both windows one and chrome one)
Chrome zoom at 110%
With those settings, the problem is repeatable for me.
I have a 1920-1080 screen.
Chrome window is maxed, windows toolbar is displayed below chrome, bookmarks and address bar are taking some space at the top of Chrome.
Font size is 100% (both windows one and chrome one)
Chrome zoom at 110%
With those settings, the problem is repeatable for me.
2022年 1月11日 5:02 • JefHatch • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
In a three player game, it would randomly just put my opponents board over the top of the game board. Refresh fixed it, but it was troublesome.
2022年 1月19日 14:17 • bananasplay • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
I have my "Player boards layout" set to "Right", and a similar thing (referring to the linked image) happens to me, often between turns when I leave the game tab open: after other players have taken their turns and it's my turn again, somehow another player's board is to the right of mine, whereas when I ended my turn, it was "stacked" properly underneath my board.
2022年 1月20日 11:52 • bananasplay • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
A further comment to make: I've noticed, on multiple tables, that when my discard pile is of "sufficient" size and I click on it to display its contents, the board of the player below me shifts to the right of mine, partially covering the player panels. Worse, the board shifts to the left, rendering some portion of the board out of view.
Clicking again to "collapse" the discard pile restores the viewability of the display.
What is a "sufficient" size of discard pile that triggers this behaviour? In a 3er game of the original edition, 7 cards is not a sufficient size; however, in a 3er game of the second edition, 9 cards /is/ a sufficient size.
Should I attempt to provide more detail on this behaviour as I continue encountering it?
Clicking again to "collapse" the discard pile restores the viewability of the display.
What is a "sufficient" size of discard pile that triggers this behaviour? In a 3er game of the original edition, 7 cards is not a sufficient size; however, in a 3er game of the second edition, 9 cards /is/ a sufficient size.
Should I attempt to provide more detail on this behaviour as I continue encountering it?
2022年 1月20日 13:45 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Hey, thanks for debugging this for me :)
I followed a RT game yesterday with left / right layout to see what happened.
I came to the same conclusion as you: when elements (like objective cards) go on multiple lines visually, then the display get broken.
I followed a RT game yesterday with left / right layout to see what happened.
I came to the same conclusion as you: when elements (like objective cards) go on multiple lines visually, then the display get broken.
2022年 1月21日 6:26 • bananasplay • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Without knowing the code, your description does appear, from a user's perspective, to be consistent with what's happening, yes.
For further documentation of this bug, just now, on table 233508462 at move 80, my delivery cards went to my discard pile (i.e. subphase 4 of Kansas City), and immediately the blue player's board shifted from the "stack" underneath my board to the right of my board, displacing the main board and so on as described above.
This is especially odd to me as the blue player is neither player 2 nor player 4, but is player 3 relative to my own position as player 1 (i.e., my position at the top of the stack, since we're talking about my display here).
For further documentation of this bug, just now, on table 233508462 at move 80, my delivery cards went to my discard pile (i.e. subphase 4 of Kansas City), and immediately the blue player's board shifted from the "stack" underneath my board to the right of my board, displacing the main board and so on as described above.
This is especially odd to me as the blue player is neither player 2 nor player 4, but is player 3 relative to my own position as player 1 (i.e., my position at the top of the stack, since we're talking about my display here).
2022年 1月26日 17:29 • bananasplay • 錯誤已修復:
Not sure that it is fixed, though... I've loaded at least one table since this fix and there's been a board to the right of mine.
Instead of F5, I click open the option gear and click "Left" then "Right" under "Player boards layout", and that fixes it for me.
Instead of F5, I click open the option gear and click "Left" then "Right" under "Player boards layout", and that fixes it for me.
2022年 1月26日 18:31 • docthib • 錯誤已修復:
argh -.-
so it was at loading only? did you reproduce the behavior every time?
Last time I played with this feature I didn't get visual bug anymore.
Will give it another shot, maybe I broke something
so it was at loading only? did you reproduce the behavior every time?
Last time I played with this feature I didn't get visual bug anymore.
Will give it another shot, maybe I broke something
2022年 1月27日 2:05 • bananasplay • 錯誤已修復:
No, not at loading only—I could trigger it in certain cases after the table had otherwise loaded properly (as described above :-).
There's seemingly no way of predicting when this happens upon loading; and F5 does fix the issue, as does my quicker "Right-Left" fix.
For example, I just loaded table 235554423 at move 99 and it loaded with this display bug, but I can't seem to force the bug to happen again /upon loading/. But I /can/, by expanding and collapsing my discard pile, force the bug to happen at will.
There's seemingly no way of predicting when this happens upon loading; and F5 does fix the issue, as does my quicker "Right-Left" fix.
For example, I just loaded table 235554423 at move 99 and it loaded with this display bug, but I can't seem to force the bug to happen again /upon loading/. But I /can/, by expanding and collapsing my discard pile, force the bug to happen at will.
2022年 1月27日 2:09 • bananasplay • 錯誤已修復:
Here's something that I noticed, but first some background:
I normally play with my discard pile collapsed, and it's when I expand that pile that I can often (but not always) trigger this bug. When I collapse the pile again, the display resumes normal appearance.
However, here's what I notice:
When I expand my discard pile, which triggers the bug, if I click "Left" then "Right" again under "Player boards layout", the display again resumes normal appearance, even though the discard pile is still expanded. Now, however, when I collapse and expand the discard pile, the display bug doesn't recur.
Is this enough detail to convey what's happening in this particular situation?
I normally play with my discard pile collapsed, and it's when I expand that pile that I can often (but not always) trigger this bug. When I collapse the pile again, the display resumes normal appearance.
However, here's what I notice:
When I expand my discard pile, which triggers the bug, if I click "Left" then "Right" again under "Player boards layout", the display again resumes normal appearance, even though the discard pile is still expanded. Now, however, when I collapse and expand the discard pile, the display bug doesn't recur.
Is this enough detail to convey what's happening in this particular situation?
2022年 1月28日 22:32 • docthib • 錯誤已修復:
Wait wait! I never asked you but, do you play with floating player hand / board?
I realized with player hand NOT floating the display is broken ^^
Thanks again for your help
I realized with player hand NOT floating the display is broken ^^
Thanks again for your help
2022年 1月29日 0:45 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Ok so I reworked the way to compute this. Didn't have issues anymore even without floating stuff.
I wish I could make you test before deploying next patch haha :)
I wish I could make you test before deploying next patch haha :)
2022年 1月30日 19:01 • bananasplay • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Sorry, I just noticed the question now; BGA e-mailed me with your most recent comment, but not the one prior where your question appeared.
No, I don't play with either the floating player board or cards—I hated having a huge part of the board obscured, so I immediately disabled those options in my first game. :-$
No, I don't play with either the floating player board or cards—I hated having a huge part of the board obscured, so I immediately disabled those options in my first game. :-$
2022年 1月31日 1:55 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
I should have asked before. Now I tested with your configuration and it seems way better :)
2022年 1月31日 10:13 • bananasplay • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
I've been paying attention to my tables particularly since you announced the patch... anecdotally, the bug seems to happen less often, but it hasn't gone away entirely.
Perhaps try playing all the way through a few games with my configuration, and I'm sure that you'll see it crop up from time to time. :-)
In any case, thanks again for not ignoring this seemingly situational bug. :-)
Perhaps try playing all the way through a few games with my configuration, and I'm sure that you'll see it crop up from time to time. :-)
In any case, thanks again for not ignoring this seemingly situational bug. :-)
2022年 1月31日 12:12 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
It's not patched yet :)
(the "reworked" version of this feature)
You will see my patch note in group then and I will post here when it's the case.
(the "reworked" version of this feature)
You will see my patch note in group then and I will post here when it's the case.
2022年 2月21日 10:12 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
I think this should be fixed as well (v0.6.0)
If it happens to you again, please try to identify what caused it (undo, resize, which action...)
Thanks
If it happens to you again, please try to identify what caused it (undo, resize, which action...)
Thanks
2022年 2月24日 9:02 • bananasplay • 錯誤已修復:
After a few days, the bug no longer seems to happen just when the game loads, but it still happens /sometimes/ when one's hand or discard pile (or both) are expanded.
I've uploaded a few screenshots here... hopefully the descriptions therein are sufficiently clear, but please let me know if not. :-)
imgur.com/a/3EgGOzD
I've uploaded a few screenshots here... hopefully the descriptions therein are sufficiently clear, but please let me know if not. :-)
imgur.com/a/3EgGOzD
2022年 3月 7日 14:43 • bananasplay • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
imgur.com/a/V0tDV5l
Took this screenshot since the bug happened at the very start of this game, where my hand was expanded to allow me to discard down to four cards.
I don't think the circumstances are fundamentally different from the other situations, but now I see that if the table is set for the Second Edition, this will happen to players 3 and 4 (and possibly 2) with certain browsers right at the start.
Took this screenshot since the bug happened at the very start of this game, where my hand was expanded to allow me to discard down to four cards.
I don't think the circumstances are fundamentally different from the other situations, but now I see that if the table is set for the Second Edition, this will happen to players 3 and 4 (and possibly 2) with certain browsers right at the start.
2022年 3月 7日 15:37 • docthib • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Yes, this is due to animation delay :(
Because display compute is usually done on click and not after element finished their positioning ><
Because display compute is usually done on click and not after element finished their positioning ><
2022年 3月 8日 10:01 • bananasplay • 開發者已確認這項錯誤:
Ah, interesting. At least we now know why this happens, though. Thanks for the update! :-)
2022年 4月12日 20:04 • docthib • 開發者需要更多資訊以重現這項錯誤:
Added some improvements in v0.7.0
Has anyone still have issues?
Has anyone still have issues?
為本案件添加內容
任何可能重現這項錯誤或了解你的建議之相關資訊，都請在此填寫:
- 其他同樣狀況的桌號／步數
- 按 F5 是否解決了這個問題？
- 問題是否發生了好幾次？每次都發生？時好時壞？
- 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。
