案件 • Board Game Arena

所有案件

太空基地的案件

#62199: "Instantly Win-Card - Allow active player to finish their turn"

acknowledged: 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行

這是關於哪方面的案件？

太空基地 #256132304

發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇

建議：依我所見，有些調整將大幅增進遊戲完成度

發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇

建議：依我所見，有些調整將大幅增進遊戲完成度

請檢查是否已有同課題案件

若肯定，請「投票」給這樁案件。最高票的案件將「優先」處理！

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

細節描述

案件沿革

2022年Apr4日 15:35 • katicilli • 此建議尚未被開發者分析過:

2022年Apr4日 20:54 • diamant • 此建議尚未被開發者分析過:

Rule, page 26 :
"When you use this ability, points are irrelevant; the game ends immediately and you win!"

If points are irrelevant, then there is one winner and tied losers.

Obviously, in view of your report, BGA applies a different rule, which is acceptable only if it is approved by the author or publisher of the game, and especially known to the players.
Your proposal makes sense, but it concerns an unofficial rule applied by BGA, the legitimacy of which must first be verified.

2022年Apr21日 17:40 • montsegur • 此建議尚未被開發者分析過:

I agree that you should have a chance to finish your move. Else it s a reaction test and nothing else who gets 2nd , 3rd , 4th and 5th. I ve just been 4th instead of second. Don t take the word IMMEDIATELY literally.

2022年Apr21日 17:46 • montsegur • 此建議尚未被開發者分析過:

The rules say:

When you
use this ability, points are irrelevant; the
game ends immediately and you win! Do
not finish the round. If another player has
more than 40 you win anyway.

it says Do not finish the ROUND, but you should allow to finish the turn of the active player.

2023年Mar20日 02:01 • critternation • 此建議尚未被開發者分析過:

boardgamearena.com/table?table=358406816 yes it's very frustrating I was about to go up to 3rd or 2nd here but getting robbed of my turn means I end last and rank down instead of up in arena play.

2023年Mar20日 14:09 • Shazzypaz • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

I agree that this is an issue on BGA if positions other than 1st place are ranked.

2023年Mar27日 18:50 • diamant • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

@critternation: This report is for instantaneous gain with the U. E. S. ARMSTRONG 6927-D. Now, in the game you’re referencing, this space ship is not in the hands of any player.

So, your comment is off topic, and if it still concerns an existing bug, you’d better create a new bug report.

2023年Oct10日 21:27 • Andrew C-137 • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

Been discussing this with my regular play group and seems that it should go one of two ways:

If you're going to place players using their score up till that point (which goes contrary to the SB ruleset), you should let the turn finish so that rewards may be collected. That could mean the difference between 4th and 2nd and shouldn't be dictated by player's mousing abilities.

I believe that it probably should end right away and the points are irrelevant as the rule states, but the question is: "Is everyone tied for the first available place (i.e. 2nd) or is everyone tied for last?"

In most cases ties go to the first available place, which we see in BGA behaviour when two people are tied for 2nd for example (40, 36, 36, 31). While it's tempting to say "of course that's how you do it," I would suggest that doing it that way might lessen the win of the player using the You Win card. I don't know enough about how ELO is implemented here, but if the winner's gain is based on the position of each player in a multi player game, then the other players finishing 4th might result in better ELO gain for the winner.

In any case, the BGA system may not allow for "setting places" so probably the only practical thing to do is when the You Win is activated, that the other players scores is reset to 0 and they all tie for second.

2023年Oct10日 21:53 • Shazzypaz • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

@Andrew C-137: It's not just an issue for players' mousing abilities. It's also an issue in turn-based games where some players aren't online to play their next turn before the You Win card is activated. So players have not had an equal chance to score points for the ranking. I hadn't considered that all players would be tied for 2nd. At the moment I am thinking that players would be ranked by their final score, which is consistent with other games - if you don't think you can win, then play for 2nd; there should be a way to at least elevate your position.

I don't yet have permission from the publisher to implement any variants like this.

2023年Oct11日 01:42 • Andrew C-137 • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

@Shazzypaz Indeed - the Turn-Based issue is even more prominent (I don't play TB games so wasn't top of mind).

For sure - either way would be an improvement - let the turn finish or rank all the non winning players the same. IMHO I think ranking them all the same would be more consistent with the standard rules of the game as it does say "When you use this ability, <B>points are irrelevant</B>; the game ends immediately and you win!"

I often play for 2nd place when it's clear someone else is going to win, but feel like getting ranked after the You Win gets activated isn't a great metric.

It will be interesting to see what JDC and the folks at AEG say - it may not even be a variant; rather a move to adhere closer to the rules.

Thanks for looking into this!

2023年Nov26日 17:26 • Pseudo Q • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

Our game of it just finished with the "You Win" card, with some people benefiting from Red rewards, and others not, which changed relative order of those in 2nd and below, and rank points won/lost might have been different.
Either everyone should get their benefits, or nobody should, not just the active player.

2024年Aug25日 18:26 • Jeno73 • 開發者認同這是個好點子，並計劃實行:

I will set the winning player to 40 points, the others to 20, because it is easier than extending the game, and because it is more consistent to the rulebook. Obviously rulebooks usually don't consider tournaments.

為本案件添加內容

任何可能重現這項錯誤或了解你的建議之相關資訊，都請在此填寫:

其他同樣狀況的桌號／步數
按 F5 是否解決了這個問題？
問題是否發生了好幾次？每次都發生？時好時壞？
建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。

取消更新案情

#62199: "Instantly Win-Card - Allow active player to finish their turn"

這是關於哪方面的案件？

發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇

發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇

請檢查是否已有同課題案件

細節描述

案件沿革

為本案件添加內容

更改案件狀態為：

說明

貢獻

導覽

追蹤我們