所有案件
花見小路 的案件
#86869: "more than 3 rounds"
notabug: 這並非程式錯誤
1
這是關於哪方面的案件?
發生什麼事? 請從下方選擇
規則:遊戲規則有所錯漏
細節描述
• 遊戲規則的哪部分在 BGA 版本有所錯漏?
a game should only last 3 rounds (on maximum). winner then would be the player with more points• 這項違反規則之處可否在遊戲重播中看到?若可以是在哪步?(重播時左上角資訊)
my game lasted 4 rounds• 你的瀏覽器是什麼?
Google Chrome v111
案件沿革
2023年 4月21日 16:29 •
2023年 4月21日 16:54 •
Broxi4769 • 這項錯誤已被回報過:
2023年 5月23日 16:35 • I had this 2 times already.
If after the 3rd round, nobody won with 11 points or winning 4 girls, the game continues, specially if points are 8:9 something like this.
So the rule is, that the person with 9 points is the winner (more than 8), but the game continues until one has 4 girls or 11 points. This is wrong. The game always ends after 3 rounds.
If after the 3rd round, nobody won with 11 points or winning 4 girls, the game continues, specially if points are 8:9 something like this.
So the rule is, that the person with 9 points is the winner (more than 8), but the game continues until one has 4 girls or 11 points. This is wrong. The game always ends after 3 rounds.
username314 • 這項錯誤已被回報過:
2023年 5月30日 2:51 • as I know, that is optional. before starting playerscan choice if mostly 3 rounds
ufm • 這並非程式錯誤:
2023年 5月30日 4:35 • Again, I cannot find such tiebreakers in the rulebook from EmperorS4 homepage:
drive.google.com/file/d/0B-UUhGhkNzLsdTBYX1U5a25xWjg/view?resourcekey=0-NShuowDi1-Upj_VOu7wUQA
This implementation is following EmperorS4 rules according to the license agreement.
drive.google.com/file/d/0B-UUhGhkNzLsdTBYX1U5a25xWjg/view?resourcekey=0-NShuowDi1-Upj_VOu7wUQA
This implementation is following EmperorS4 rules according to the license agreement.
Broxi4769 • 這並非程式錯誤:
2023年 5月30日 8:48 • Hi UFM,
okay, with the given rule book, I agree that there it is not stated that after 3 rounds there is an end.
I have an older version of the game, where it is clearly stated.
So I agree, as you need to build the game according to the actual rules...then its no error.
However...a game can last then forever... I played for over 6 rounds with no winner... and we both agreed to cancel the game...as we both knew the rule, that after 3 rounds there is a finish.
A lot of players will not like the game this way, as they learned it differently. Maybe you can ask the publisher if they might made a mistake?
There is some discussion on this topic on BGG:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2181503/rules-differences-regarding-endless-play-tie-break
but with no real result....
okay, with the given rule book, I agree that there it is not stated that after 3 rounds there is an end.
I have an older version of the game, where it is clearly stated.
So I agree, as you need to build the game according to the actual rules...then its no error.
However...a game can last then forever... I played for over 6 rounds with no winner... and we both agreed to cancel the game...as we both knew the rule, that after 3 rounds there is a finish.
A lot of players will not like the game this way, as they learned it differently. Maybe you can ask the publisher if they might made a mistake?
There is some discussion on this topic on BGG:
boardgamegeek.com/thread/2181503/rules-differences-regarding-endless-play-tie-break
but with no real result....
ufm • 這並非程式錯誤:
2023年 5月30日 10:42 • I have no qualms about the rules.
If you want something to be changed, you should contact them.
If you want something to be changed, you should contact them.
Stroegli • 這並非程式錯誤:
2023年11月26日 6:45 •
2023年11月26日 9:17 • Hi Emma,
First of all thanks a lot for your reply.
BUT: "Broxi4769" is absolutely right with his points - the rule you show with the link is not an "official" one from the game if you buy it - AND: he is also right that a game can last then forever.
Hanamikoji is soooo nice also it is strictly limited in time with 2 rounds.
So again I would kindly ask if you might overthink this and implement this restriction.
Best and kind regards!
First of all thanks a lot for your reply.
BUT: "Broxi4769" is absolutely right with his points - the rule you show with the link is not an "official" one from the game if you buy it - AND: he is also right that a game can last then forever.
Hanamikoji is soooo nice also it is strictly limited in time with 2 rounds.
So again I would kindly ask if you might overthink this and implement this restriction.
Best and kind regards!
bryancarol07 • 這並非程式錯誤:
2024年 5月12日 3:24 • The official rules say than if there's no winner after the round 3 then the game end. The winner will be the one with the more poins and if there's a drawn again then there is no winner. We should implement an option to play either as many round as we want + another option with the real rules saying than we stop after 3 round
You can see the rules talking about the end of the games in Page 11
FRENCH RULES
iello.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Hanamikoji_rulebook_FR_V1-Light.pdf
Si, après 3 manches, aucun joueur n’a encore rempli de condition de victoire, le gagnant est le joueur avec le plus de points Art. S’il y a égalité, la partie se termine, et il n’y a pas de gagnant
GERMAN RULES
fragkosmos.zendesk.com/hc/de/article_attachments/13286328977948
Falls nach 3 Runden noch immer kein Spieler die Siegbedingung erfüllt hat, gewinnt der Spieler mit mehr Gunstpunkten. Bei Gleichstand endet das Spiel unentschieden.
ENGLISH TRADUCTION
If, after 3 rounds, no player has yet met the victory condition, the winner is the player with the most points Art. If there is a tie, the game ends, and there is no winner
You can see the rules talking about the end of the games in Page 11
FRENCH RULES
iello.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Hanamikoji_rulebook_FR_V1-Light.pdf
Si, après 3 manches, aucun joueur n’a encore rempli de condition de victoire, le gagnant est le joueur avec le plus de points Art. S’il y a égalité, la partie se termine, et il n’y a pas de gagnant
GERMAN RULES
fragkosmos.zendesk.com/hc/de/article_attachments/13286328977948
Falls nach 3 Runden noch immer kein Spieler die Siegbedingung erfüllt hat, gewinnt der Spieler mit mehr Gunstpunkten. Bei Gleichstand endet das Spiel unentschieden.
ENGLISH TRADUCTION
If, after 3 rounds, no player has yet met the victory condition, the winner is the player with the most points Art. If there is a tie, the game ends, and there is no winner
為本案件添加內容
任何可能重現這項錯誤或了解你的建議之相關資訊,都請在此填寫:
- 其他同樣狀況的桌號/步數
- 按 F5 是否解決了這個問題?
- 問題是否發生了好幾次?每次都發生?時好時壞?
- 建議將此錯誤的螢幕截圖上傳到 Imgur.com 並轉貼連結。